Even Thirst
كتب لهم
Chapter 1

His heart is sinful

From the Qur'an (Sûrat al-Baqara, Sûrat at-Tawba) and its commentators
Sûrat al-Baqara · 2:283

O you who believe, when you contract a debt for a fixed term, write it down.

Do not tire of writing it down, small or large, with its term.

2:282 is the longest verse of the Qur'an: 144 words on a debt, a scribe who writes fairly, and witnesses.

Do not conceal testimony.

Whoever conceals it, his heart is sinful.

Read it again. It does not say: he is sinful. It says: his heart is sinful, âthimun qalbuhu.

Concealing a testimony is done by keeping silent: a fault of the tongue, you would think. The verse names the heart.

Al-Qurtubî asks why the heart is singled out. His first answer: concealing is one of the acts of the heart.

His second: the heart is the morsel of flesh by which, when it is sound, the whole body is sound.

The Prophet ﷺ said: there is a piece of flesh in the body; if it is sound, the whole body is sound. It is the heart.

Al-Qurtubî also cites al-Kiyâ: decided in the heart, held back by the tongue. The sin is on both.

And he concludes: “his heart is sinful” is a figure of speech, and a stronger warning than plain words would be.

Key idea
Silence can be a sin. And the Qur'an names where it starts: in the heart.

Ibn 'Abbâs (may Allah be pleased with him): false testimony is among the greatest sins; hiding a true one is the same.

“His heart is sinful”: that is, say the early commentators, fâjirun qalbuhu, his heart is corrupt.

The Day when neither wealth nor children will benefit,

except the one who comes to Allah with a sound heart.

Qalbun salîm, a sound heart: a heart free of impurity and of shirk, unlike the sick hearts of 2:10.

The expression comes twice in the Qur'an: here, in a prayer of Ibrâhîm (peace be upon him), and in 37:84, about him.

Put the two verses side by side: a heart that sins by hiding, and the only heart that will count on that Day.

Key idea
Honesty in a deal is not only a matter of words. The Qur'an places it in the heart, and Allah knows what you do.

The longest verse of the Qur'an is about a debt, a scribe and two witnesses.

Right after it, one phrase names the sinner. Not the man: his heart.

A debt written down, a witness who speaks, a heart that hides nothing: this is what the longest verse asks of you.

Tonight, think of one thing you owe someone, money or a word held back, and settle what you can.

True or false?

In 2:283, whoever conceals testimony “is sinful”, and the verse names no part of him.

Select an answer

Why does 2:283 name the heart?